Wednesday, February 18, 2015

Session 7-Are democracies truly representative?

“Democracy must be something more than two wolves and a sheep voting on what to have for dinner.”
― James Bovard, Lost Rights: The Destruction of American Liberty
Representative democracy is a system of government whereby ordinary people elect officials of the government who are then mandated to take decisions on behalf of the public and represent it’s views. While in theory this form of government seems to offer empowerment and liberty, in reality the workings of this system make this a difficult ideal to achieve, especially in third world countries such as Pakistan.

Firstly, representative democracies are thought to reflect the views of the entire population as everyone gets an equal chance to vote and elect officials .However, this argument is rendered invalid when we consider the premise of the irrationality of the average voter. Not only are most people uninformed about political issues, they hold strong biases about the issues that they have knowledge of. Moreover voting preferences are strongly characterized by prejudice. For example many voters tend to be influenced by personalities and short lived political campaigns rather than manifestos. Furthermore, in countries such as Pakistan there are external pressures that influence voter decisions such as family bias and economic pressures.

Moreover, the electoral system usually puts forth candidates that are either middle class or elite. This means that power is no equally distributed as most persons in power belong to the group of the hegemonic elitist minority rather than the majority.


In conclusion, all these factors prevent democracies from truly representing people or achieving the ideals of equality.

No comments: